UnderGround Forums Edgar was never the champ in the 1st place


2/3/13 2:04 PM
10/30/03
Posts: 15524
He lost the 1st fight to BJ. He's the king of a judges decision that went his way. Quit bitching about this one and go back and watch the 1st BJ fight.
2/3/13 2:06 PM
10/30/03
Posts: 15525
I FEEL MY BAN COMING BUT I AM A MARTYR FOR THE TRUTH!




Tell The Truth!
2/3/13 2:13 PM
5/13/11
Posts: 17531

I feel like Aldo much more clearly beat Edgar than Edgar "beating" BJ the first time. 

2/3/13 2:14 PM
1/1/01
Posts: 43174
Yeah but no one argues that Edgar beat BJ in the rematch.
2/3/13 2:16 PM
1/1/08
Posts: 7106

Edgar was busier, but Aldo landed more and landed harder. Close fight, but I think the judges got it right.

 

2/3/13 2:17 PM
1/1/01
Posts: 43176
Chaelismyhero - Dont feed the troll

My bad.
2/3/13 2:17 PM
10/30/03
Posts: 15527
nom nom nom. Yum.
2/3/13 2:26 PM
1/1/01
Posts: 11793
imo edgar penn 1, penn should have earned the decision. especially since (at the time) he was the champ. imo you have to take the belt away in relatively decisive fashion.

edgar penn 2 may have happened regardless and imo edgar took that one and would have taken the belt...so he'd be the champ.
2/3/13 2:40 PM
8/1/03
Posts: 76116

Since Penn had had no competitive LW fights in the first place, they would have had a rematch even if judges had given him the close win in the first fight...and Frankie still would have dominated.

2/3/13 2:43 PM
12/25/05
Posts: 25145
Rewriting history. Ahmadinejad would be proud.
2/3/13 2:45 PM
10/30/03
Posts: 15531
Praise Allah