UnderGround Forums Judge removed by Dana @UFN

8/23/14 11:49 AM
2/24/11
Posts: 292
As per post fight conference!
Was told to "get a beer and popcorn and watch some fights"!

UPDATE:

It's now on the first page:
http://www.mixedmartialarts.com/news/446833/White-puts-judge-Howard-Hughes-out-to-pasture-at-UFN-48/


At UFC Fight Night 48, Milana Dudieva won a controversial decision over Elizabeth Phillips, and Royston Wee won a controversial decision over Yao Zhikui. Under ordinary circumstances, the event is entirely regulated by a State, provincial, or tribal regulating body. In Macau however, the UFC self regulates, and this time UFC president Dana White had the means to respond - he had word sent to judge Howard Hughes that it was time to enjoy the fights, from the stands.

“He was involved in the first fight and the second fight,” said White to John Morgan for MMAFighting. “I told the guys to go let him grab some beer and some popcorn and go sit down and start watching some fights, not judging them."

“I know a lot of people, the media included and the fans I saw on Twitter, felt that Phillips won the fight, but I thought Milana won the fight, so I disagree. But at the end of the day, who gives a s–- what I think. It’s the judges. They pick the winner, and that’s all that matters.”

“It wasn’t great tonight (of officiating). It wasn’t, and it drives me crazy. So, I can sit there and ridicule Nevada, California and all these other places we go, but nobody to point the finger at tonight except for us.”
8/23/14 11:53 AM
1/23/10
Posts: 5993
The one who scored it 30-27 for the Russian girl? Phone Post 3.0
8/23/14 11:58 AM
9/15/07
Posts: 4671
Interesting Phone Post 3.0
8/23/14 11:59 AM
2/24/11
Posts: 293
Ch1ef - The one who scored it 30-27 for the Russian girl? Phone Post 3.0

I was just tuning in and from what I gather it was after the first 2 fights.
I am not able to confirm since I caught the card @ Wang Anying vs. Colby Covington (the 3rd fight)

VU for clarication
8/23/14 12:02 PM
10/29/10
Posts: 2065
So does the UFC act as the commissioners in Macau?
8/23/14 12:05 PM
1/23/10
Posts: 5994
Eunuchorn - So does the UFC act as the commissioners in Macau?
In a manner of speaking.

Phone Post 3.0
8/23/14 12:06 PM
2/24/11
Posts: 294
Eunuchorn - So does the UFC act as the commissioners in Macau?

If I get this right, there are no commission there so they brought in everything (judges ref testing...)
8/23/14 12:23 PM
2/24/11
Posts: 296
Ch1ef - 
Eunuchorn - So does the UFC act as the commissioners in Macau?
In a manner of speaking.

Phone Post 3.0

I don't get this,care to explain?
8/23/14 12:44 PM
7/15/11
Posts: 2434
Shit the bed so to speak lol??? Phone Post 3.0
8/23/14 12:46 PM
5/2/14
Posts: 510
GrindOnLine - 
Ch1ef - 
Eunuchorn - So does the UFC act as the commissioners in Macau?
In a manner of speaking.

Phone Post 3.0

I don't get this,care to explain?

Omerta
8/23/14 12:51 PM
7/23/09
Posts: 1751
GrindOnLine - 
Ch1ef - 
Eunuchorn - So does the UFC act as the commissioners in Macau?
In a manner of speaking.

Phone Post 3.0

I don't get this,care to explain?


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q2CX20bBNJE

8/23/14 12:55 PM
12/19/13
Posts: 393
Wow. Godfather much kids? Phone Post 3.0
8/23/14 12:55 PM
1/23/10
Posts: 5996
Matrixkick - Shit the bed so to speak lol??? Phone Post 3.0
I hope not. Jesus, lol.

Zuffa went into China like the Mafioso. The horse head is a famous scene from The Godfather. Phone Post 3.0
8/23/14 1:15 PM
5/16/12
Posts: 618
. Phone Post 3.0
8/23/14 1:18 PM
11/24/07
Posts: 7245
Removed or replaced?
8/23/14 1:18 PM
12/26/07
Posts: 9913
in for details
8/23/14 1:51 PM
2/24/11
Posts: 299
ClemenzasCannoli - . Phone Post 3.0

I should get a VTFD for missing a godfather reference!
8/23/14 1:52 PM
2/24/11
Posts: 300
Ocean6 - in for details

He was first removed than replaced with someone else if that helps.
8/23/14 1:58 PM
12/28/12
Posts: 92
they removed the judge even though dana agreed with the phillips decision?
8/23/14 1:59 PM
2/24/11
Posts: 301
Ocean6 - in for details

As I said earlier, I missed the first 2 fights so I don't have a first hand opinion but, after looking at the scorecards, it seems clear that one judge was smoking the heefer instead of watching the fights.
From Sherdog Play-by_play:
Milana Dudieva
vs.
Elizabeth Phillips
Sherdog Scores
Jordan Breen scores the round 10-9 Phillips (29-28 Phillips)
Mike Fridley scores the round 10-9 Phillips (29-28 Phillips)
Brian Knapp scores the round 10-9 Phillips (29-28 Phillips)
The Official Result
Milana Dudieva def. Elizabeth Phillips via Split Decision (30-27, 29-28, 28-29) R3 5:00

28-29???
Everybody had Phillips winning except the third judge.

Royston Wee
vs.
Zhuikui Yao


Sherdog Scores
Jordan Breen scores the round 10-9 Yao (29-28 Yao)
Mike Fridley scores the round 10-9 Yao (29-28 Wee)
Brian Knapp scores the round 10-9 Yao (29-29 Draw)
The Official Result
Royston Wee def. Zhuikui Yao via Split Decision (29-28, 29-28, 27-30) R3 5:00

27-30???
Close fight could have gone either way it seems except for the 3rd judge who had the clear winner with 27-30

8/23/14 2:00 PM
2/24/11
Posts: 302
evh - they removed the judge even though dana agreed with the phillips decision?

Look at my post below yours.
8/23/14 2:53 PM
10/17/09
Posts: 101
Dudieva vs Phillips

Anthony Dimitriou 30-27 Dudieva
Gareth Harriman 29-28 Phillips
Howard Hughes 29-28 Dudieva


Wee vs Zhikui

Howard Hughes 29-28 Wee
Charlie Keech 30-27 Zhikui
Paul Sutherland 29-28 Wee

Hughes was the only judge in both and didn't give either of the 30-27 scores.The scores I posted are from mmadecisions.
8/23/14 3:02 PM
2/24/11
Posts: 305
Primetyme199 - Dudieva vs Phillips

Anthony Dimitriou 30-27 Dudieva
Gareth Harriman 29-28 Phillips
Howard Hughes 29-28 Dudieva


Wee vs Zhikui

Howard Hughes 29-28 Wee
Charlie Keech 30-27 Zhikui
Paul Sutherland 29-28 Wee

Hughes was the only judge in both and didn't give either of the 30-27 scores.The scores I posted are from mmadecisions.

VU for clarification.
Now I'm confused.
So, who got the boot???
8/23/14 3:04 PM
10/17/09
Posts: 102
It had to be Hughes, since Dana said the judge was involved in the 2 fights. The only thing possible is mmadecisions has the scores attributed to the wrong judges.
8/23/14 3:24 PM
10/10/06
Posts: 877
How bout blaf just appoints himself as the sole judge for all ufc fights now?? Phone Post 3.0