UnderGround Forums what a joke this ufc is becoming

2/3/13 12:57 AM
7/14/11
Posts: 3212
it's stupid expecting it to change. the judges are completely undertrained and inconsistent. I am not even a fan of Frankie Edgar but he won the last 3 rounds and hearing the judges scores were just ridiculous. I don't know what needs to be done but god damn it's getting dumb. Phone Post
2/3/13 12:57 AM
7/14/11
Posts: 3213
I know it's not the UFC who judges but it really really hurts their brand Phone Post
2/3/13 12:58 AM
12/1/05
Posts: 12307
Prepare to be flamed.

That said, i also thought Frank won fairly squarely. Phone Post
2/3/13 12:58 AM
12/17/11
Posts: 1901
Butt hurt? Aldo won. Phone Post
2/3/13 12:58 AM
3/5/11
Posts: 955
He lost the first three and the 5th was close.
I'm sure some people are blinded by hype.
2/3/13 12:58 AM
8/31/10
Posts: 1236
Two rounds at best. Phone Post
2/3/13 12:59 AM
6/17/11
Posts: 12233
luckily everyone who thought Frankie won were wrong

it's cool that we saw it differently but the doom and gloom about a fight that wasn't even that close is kind of silly an anooying
2/3/13 12:59 AM
1/1/01
Posts: 8074
Bofbro - He lost the first three and the 5th was close.
I'm sure some people are blinded by hype.
Yep Phone Post
2/3/13 12:59 AM
5/13/05
Posts: 1970
Aldo won the first 3 rounds.
2/3/13 1:00 AM
2/16/10
Posts: 4476
The judges did fine tonight.

i wanted Edgar to win but he lost 3 maybe for rounds tonight.

Most of the punches rogan was flipping out about missed an Rogan missed most of the punches Aldo was landing. Phone Post
2/3/13 1:00 AM
2/4/08
Posts: 229
Frankie's problem is that aside from that one slam takedown in round 4 what did he do that was significant? He doesn't cause any damage so it becomes a very subjective scoring decision based on preferences of $tyles (without the dollar sign that word is censored?? wow)
2/3/13 1:00 AM
12/8/12
Posts: 16
Come on now even if you thought Edgar won the last 3 rounds it was still close. The third round was close no need to cry about it
2/3/13 1:00 AM
9/5/11
Posts: 6291
It's a fight.

I could tell by looking at them who won. Phone Post
2/3/13 1:01 AM
10/16/08
Posts: 722

Good grief....

 

2/3/13 1:01 AM
11/3/12
Posts: 332
huh... so people disagree about who won??? well fuck you guys im just gonna blame joe rogan
2/3/13 1:01 AM
8/2/12
Posts: 6
Jason -
Bofbro - He lost the first three and the 5th was close.
I'm sure some people are blinded by hype.
Yep Phone Post
This Phone Post
2/3/13 1:01 AM
1/1/01
Posts: 11556
Yes, a case can be made for Frankie winning the last 3 rounds.
2/3/13 1:02 AM
3/30/04
Posts: 20154
ttt
2/3/13 1:02 AM
11/5/12
Posts: 44
I'm gonna love the day when Edgar either finishes or gets finished in the first. Great fight, but the never ending debates are getting old. Phone Post
2/3/13 1:02 AM
8/7/12
Posts: 4527
Aldo won the first 3
2/3/13 1:03 AM
12/31/10
Posts: 432
At the very least Edgar was robbed of a closer decision that might have initiated talk of a rematch. Phone Post
2/3/13 1:03 AM
2/4/08
Posts: 230
Stea1th - 

YOU HAVE TO BEAT THE CHAMP. NOT BARELY BEAT THE CHAMP. 


This is a holdover from boxing and I think it is ridiculous. There is nothing mythological about being THE CHAMP. The winner is the winner.
2/3/13 1:04 AM
12/10/09
Posts: 312
Jason - 
Bofbro - He lost the first three and the 5th was close.
I'm sure some people are blinded by hype.
Yep Phone Post

 

To what "hype" are you referring? Rogan had Frankie losing the 3rd. Also is hailed as amazing and they were on his nuts the whole first 2.5 rounds. Frankie was the underdog. Rogan had Aldo winning the fight. So where was the hype for Frankie? When people concluded that Frankie won...or AT LEAST did better than 49-46, they must have formed their own opion, right?? Since the broadcasters had a differing one...right??

I wont go off the deep end saying he was robbed, but I thought he won 3,4 & 5 and I'd never really considered myself a Frankie fan.

 

2/3/13 1:04 AM
10/12/09
Posts: 74
I think it is hard to complain about judges when you read this and other threads and see the difference in opinions of who won. everybody sees the fights differently. I know sometimes a judge does really blow a decision but most of the time you have many different people with different opinions.
2/3/13 1:04 AM
4/5/08
Posts: 1759
You didn't watch the fight I watched, TS. I think you were rooting for Frankie too much. I was rooting for him too, but I had it Aldo as the winner right when the final horn rang. Frankie needed to take it away and he never did it.