UnderGround Forum >> Rampage: Jon Jones' oblique kick should be banned
| 1/23/13 3:01 AM | |
Chaz Johnson
3
Member Since: 11/24/11 Posts: 685 |
Messing up someone's knee is like elbowing the back of someone's funny bone it's dirty and can cause too much damage or end a career. Having nerve damage sucks
|
| 1/23/13 11:25 AM | |
|
OmaGogo
Member Since: 12/21/10 Posts: 4 |
This is not like the NFL where someone is hitting you in the knee blindsided. The guy is right in front of you. Close the range and he can't do it. Stay out of range and he can't do it. It is important to be able to slow down powerful wrestlers and clinch fighters when you are neither of those things. Deal with it, game plan for it. Stop whining. |
| 1/23/13 11:31 AM | |
|
andyman011
Member Since: 12/7/11 Posts: 843 |
OmaGogo - This is not like the NFL where someone is hitting you in the knee blindsided. The guy is right in front of you. Close the range and he can't do it. Stay out of range and he can't do it.Close the range and you lose your knee dude. The second you step in he throws it
|
| 1/23/13 11:33 AM | |
WrestlingSucks
10
Member Since: 12/30/03 Posts: 19747 |
I agree with that kick being bullshit. I dont want to see anyone get a career ending injury. Its a sport. I dont know why he singled Jones out though. Condit and many other fighters use it |
| 1/23/13 11:54 AM | |
|
OmaGogo
Member Since: 12/21/10 Posts: 5 |
andyman011 -OmaGogo - This is not like the NFL where someone is hitting you in the knee blindsided. The guy is right in front of you. Close the range and he can't do it. Stay out of range and he can't do it.Close the range and you lose your knee dude. The second you step in he throws it If you sit in front of him mesmerized, yes. If you actually CLOSE THE RANGE, no. By definition, he cannot do it when you close the range. You need to create angles, use feints, and other techniques. It is a complaint of the lazy. |
| 1/23/13 1:43 PM | |
r_o_y
5
Member Since: 12/22/10 Posts: 1133 |
Lol its a kick to the knee in a sport where people get bashed in the head on regular basis. What next you want leg and arm locks banned? |
| 1/23/13 2:04 PM | |
|
ReneH
Member Since: 1/1/01 Posts: 2907 |
I think Wing Chun and Savate should be banned from the UFC. Too dangerous? |
| 1/23/13 3:29 PM | |
|
saemskin
Member Since: 6/30/10 Posts: 215 |
"Erickson asked what combative sports disallow this maneuver. It was noted that these kicks are not allowed in kick boxing but that is due to the fact that kicks below the waist are not allowed." that is news to me. Is K1 not kickboxing? |
| 1/23/13 3:47 PM | |
|
Kimbos Bread
Member Since: 4/11/10 Posts: 3613 |
JLau'sWarmnessSpewingAllOverMyFace - I can't wait for G-lover Tex to serve this chump ass his walking papers.It won't happen
|
| 1/23/13 4:03 PM | |
PrettyBoy
10
Member Since: 7/27/07 Posts: 8770 |
Billytk - Have to agree with Rampage here that is a dirty kick (which MOST honorable fighters don't use) and is Way more dangerous then a lot of the strikes that are bannedAgree
|
| 1/23/13 9:02 PM | |
Jack Slack
827
Member Since: 1/2/12 Posts: 1340 |
Billytk - Have to agree with Rampage here that is a dirty kick (which MOST honorable fighters don't use) and is Way more dangerous then a lot of the strikes that are banned In fairness folks have only been complaining since Jones started using it. Anderson was using it to avoid engaging grapplers ages before Jones started. |
| 1/23/13 9:04 PM | |
|
Lazer MMA
Member Since: 4/24/12 Posts: 5989 |
Jack Slack -Billytk - Have to agree with Rampage here that is a dirty kick (which MOST honorable fighters don't use) and is Way more dangerous then a lot of the strikes that are banned TTT for GIF's |
| 1/23/13 9:14 PM | |
useless
66
Member Since: 6/19/02 Posts: 24766 |
The kick to the knee is banned under the CSAC. That's what the Commission told us when I used to fight at Tachi Palace.
|
| 1/24/13 12:34 PM | |
chaplinshouse
453
Member Since: 4/5/09 Posts: 3952 |
True daf Rampage! We need much safer shyts in cage like the Arona slam! on a side note one day slamming dudes on their heads will be banned. and it will likely be due to something horrific that happened (probably on national tv). imagine the worst case scenario on that. neck bone / spinal cord broken off and visible through the neck. blood spurting everywhere. murica, fuck yeah!
|
| 1/24/13 12:44 PM | |
KneeToFaceKO
164
Member Since: 9/23/08 Posts: 5569 |
IDOHARM - Fighting should be banned as well, just in case.Boom Hahaha
|
| 1/24/13 12:46 PM | |
|
Onnie804yamsaki
Member Since: 8/8/10 Posts: 2295 |
This thread is a prime example of how weed was made illegal and how the myths were taken by the masses so easily. No proof its really any more dangerous than any other technique and 90 percent of people talk about it like its an instant career ender.Ive seen it thrown at least a hundred times total in mma without an injury. Unbelievable how idiotic most people are about the sport and how willing they are to ban shit with nothing but a false non researched opinion. Its actually frightening.DERP KICK LOOK LIKE IT MAKE KNEE GO WRONG WAY.THAT NO GOOD IN FIGHTING SPORT |
| 1/24/13 12:49 PM | |
JediJitsu
31
Member Since: 11/8/09 Posts: 2924 |
rowil - I'm kind of conflicted about this, one the one hand yeah it's kind of shitty move, on the other hand, I can't really think of a good reason to ban it.The "guy" in the gif??? That's the Dean of Mean, bro... I mean come on man!
|
| 1/24/13 1:36 PM | |
|
T Bag
Member Since: 1/1/01 Posts: 5960 |
Onnie804yamsaki - This thread is a prime example of how weed was made illegal and how the myths were taken by the masses so easily. 100% correct. I can guarantee you that another 50 idiots will still come into this thread and post "HePR bLoWN oUT KNeES dERP!" |
| 1/24/13 3:47 PM | |
|
andyman011
Member Since: 12/7/11 Posts: 851 |
I got a question for you guys and I'm not defending either side. An armbar is meant to hyper extend an arm the wrong way. They are dangerous, and jones elbow got popped by Vitor and went numb afterwards. We keep those because a ref usually intervenes before anything is broken. Now a kneebar is the same concept except a lot of people consider it more dangerous because knees are generally more prone to injury and when something pops in your knee it's usually permanent. Imagine if you got knee barred to the point of wanting to tap, and the ref resets you and you get knee barred again, and then another reset and another deep knee bar. The first thing you think is "man this guys knee is gonna be jacked". Now you look at the oblique kick, in most instances you can see the knee hyper extend backwards. If it pops, its an injury and most fighters won't tap because its not being cranked but it is a higher injury risk than a knee bar if not checked. Consider it yourself. Sure the side of the knee could have a higher risk of injury but that doesn't negate the fact that this is a high injury move. Anybody that fights to cause career ending injuries is an asshole regardless if your name is Anderson or jones
|
| 1/24/13 3:51 PM | |
Willin
97
Member Since: 4/20/11 Posts: 4071 |
andyman011 - I got a question for you guys and I'm not defending either side. An armbar is meant to hyper extend an arm the wrong way. They are dangerous, and jones elbow got popped by Vitor and went numb afterwards. We keep those because a ref usually intervenes before anything is broken.We're still waiting for a question.
|
| 1/24/13 3:58 PM | |
MolsonMuscles
31
Member Since: 12/30/05 Posts: 7899 |
Willin -OnlyTheStrongSurvive - This is a kick that looks way worse than it is. The goal of the kick isn't to blow out your opponents knees anyways.It's a kick intended to maintain range. Front kicks, obliques to the thigh, and jabs can all do the same things. There's no reason guys knees should be getting bent in the opposite direction when those alternatives exist. So does a kimura. |
| 1/24/13 8:26 PM | |
|
andyman011
Member Since: 12/7/11 Posts: 853 |
Willin -Got ahead of myself. Which would you rather have done to you 25 timesandyman011 - I got a question for you guys and I'm not defending either side. An armbar is meant to hyper extend an arm the wrong way. They are dangerous, and jones elbow got popped by Vitor and went numb afterwards. We keep those because a ref usually intervenes before anything is broken.We're still waiting for a question.
|
| 1/24/13 8:56 PM | |
|
noshame
Member Since: 1/1/01 Posts: 1428 |
Back in the earlier days, it was illegal to strike against any joint, arm or leg. When Jones first started throwing it, I thought it was illegal, but looked up the Unified rules. Legal. |
| 1/25/13 2:41 PM | |
Wasa-B
45
Member Since: 1/1/01 Posts: 42889 |
Onnie804yamsaki - This thread is a prime example of how weed was made illegal and how the myths were taken by the masses so easily. My stance is that aslong as its legal, its legal. However, as kickboxing is a sport that has been dealing with this issue for much longer than MMA, it does make sense to look at how they rule it. There are diff orgs out there but does anyone know org by org if its legal or not in K1, Glory, muay thai rules, etc? How is it viewed in the kickboxing world? I would trust they would be more knowledgable about this than the UG. Duke? |
| 1/25/13 4:30 PM | |
burner22
7
Member Since: 8/17/12 Posts: 750 |
Wasa-B - Hmm...its a fair point and a good discussion topic but Rampage sure does seem to whine a lot these days. A dam far cry from the "Im 23 so in 2 years I see myself as being 25" Pride Rampage.Ha are you actually quoting him there?
|
Reply Post
You must log in to post a reply. Click here to login.



