UnderGround Forum >> Is Jones Black Belt Level?
| 9/23/12 8:58 PM | |
|
Gomrad
Member Since: 7/21/09 Posts: 268 |
Caught_clean - Matt and Jon didnt learn submissions and submission defence from wrestling though. They have trained jiu jitsu weather they, or you want to admit it. Its like when Matt beat Royce and claimed he didnt use any jiu jitsu even though he took the back with hooks, and was arm locking him from halfguard haha.Hughes flatten out Royce with "both hooks" or "double boots" is a matter of your point of reference
|
| 9/23/12 8:59 PM | |
|
Winston Wolf
Member Since: 1/1/01 Posts: 32700 |
uniquetechnique -Winston Wolf -Immaculata -Winston Wolf -Immaculata -Smith1234 -Immaculata - You need to be proficient with the Gi to be a true BB. I don't know the extent of his training using one. im not going to name names but a certain MMA fighter in a lower weight than Jones walked into a prominant school I trained at .First day there he was smashing folks with GI without GI .You really think the average blackbelt can beat Jones in BJJ.Maybe hed lose against the very best But id bet anything u bring in 30 blackbelts his weight and have Jones have a BJJ match against them.I say hed win 28 to 30 times in BJJ.Dude Ive rolled with many blackbelts and not that I beat them but I dont think Id last a minute with Jones |
| 9/23/12 8:59 PM | |
Immaculata
46
Member Since: 12/14/03 Posts: 20797 |
Winston Wolf -uniquetechnique -Immaculata -Winston Wolf -Immaculata -Smith1234 -Immaculata - You need to be proficient with the Gi to be a true BB. I don't know the extent of his training using one. Watch him join that school and get a white belt get strapped around his waist. |
| 9/23/12 9:04 PM | |
yellow wrkahlc
39
Member Since: 6/9/12 Posts: 2018 |
Smith1234 - ^^ huh? Please go rewatch the fight. I have no idea what you are saying. He was going back for leg, Shogun opened up and a bomb was landed. It is not up for debate, the punch was set up and the set up worked. I don't need to watch the fight again. Jon Jones tries the goofiest things because he knows his size and reach are to his advantage and he can get away with it. He was on top of shogun, just doing whatever the hell he wanted to do. He didn't set that punch up, he just figured he'd swing at Shogun's face. Jones is technical at times, but let's not pretend he's masterful. Still very green in his stand up, but his reach bridges that gap. |
| 9/23/12 9:04 PM | |
|
BertR
Member Since: 11/10/09 Posts: 188 |
The debate is absurd. bjj rankings can only be attributed to the standards set in bjj because it is a different sport than mma. If Jones wants to know if how his grappling compares, he could go to a certified bjj instructor with an upstanding reputation and be tested. What can be said is Jones grappling in mma is enough where he can become a 17-1 champion including against fighters who are bjj blackbelts |
| 9/23/12 9:04 PM | |
D241
12
Member Since: 11/20/09 Posts: 11197 |
Gomrad - Gold Belt > Black Belt Boom /thread |
| 9/23/12 9:05 PM | |
|
Winston Wolf
Member Since: 1/1/01 Posts: 32703 |
Kostakio - I wouldn't say he's a black belt but high purple or even a brown belt for sure. But of course, with his athleticism and confidence, he sure seems like it. bring Jones to ur local BJJ club and tell me how he does.Wiedman kicked ass his first day.Jones is bigger and been grappling longer.Id say first day at Serras Wiedman was brown belt level. |
| 9/23/12 9:06 PM | |
disconnect
6
Member Since: 3/16/07 Posts: 273 |
is this even a question? jones would get tapped easily by the WORST bb in his weight division at the bjj worlds. |
| 9/23/12 9:06 PM | |
uniquetechnique
9
Member Since: 3/28/02 Posts: 4093 |
Winston Wolf -Random Hero - MMA is not BJJ. he would not have a chance in a BJJ tournament against a BB. just because he beats a BB in MMA doesnt mean he beats a BB in jiu jitsu. thats like saying Randy is better at boxing than Toney because he beat him in MMA. they are two different sports. MMA grappling isnt even close to no gi grappling nvm actual brazilian jiu jitsu. its a whole different game when you add strikes. untill they start ranking MMA fighters with belt colours, he is not a black belt. in my opinion his striking is a bigger asset to his ground game than his grappling is. Totally different winston. No-Gi..Jones would of course do absolutely good in a No-Gi Tournament...He displayed great transitions. That is because of Greg Jackson as well. Greg Jackson has been coming to Grapplers QUest for years, In fact...before Diego Sanchez, Dodson, Jardine were popular they would be seen all the time competing in the older GQ tournaments...Their grappling back then though seemed more of a wrestling than anything else. You really didn't see so much submissions from them at all...but of course time goes by and their team just gets better and better. Our team for a long time held first place for many years here in Vegas. Diego was breaking off a lot of our guys in class...until he put on a Gi. |
| 9/23/12 9:07 PM | |
|
Winston Wolf
Member Since: 1/1/01 Posts: 32704 |
Kostakio - I wouldn't say he's a black belt but high purple or even a brown belt for sure. But of course, with his athleticism and confidence, he sure seems like it. dude im purple belt for 4 years and i know lots of others and I know damn well Jones would run a clinic on me |
| 9/23/12 9:09 PM | |
Random Hero
21
Member Since: 11/24/10 Posts: 657 |
Smith1234 -Random Hero - MMA is not BJJ. he would not have a chance in a BJJ tournament against a BB. just because he beats a BB in MMA doesnt mean he beats a BB in jiu jitsu. thats like saying Randy is better at boxing than Toney because he beat him in MMA. they are two different sports. MMA grappling isnt even close to no gi grappling nvm actual brazilian jiu jitsu. its a whole different game when you add strikes. untill they start ranking MMA fighters with belt colours, he is not a black belt. in my opinion his striking is a bigger asset to his ground game than his grappling is. no gi sub wrestling is not bjj either. they dont give belts for no gi. you have to be good at gi to get your rank. gyms that only train no gi give coloured rash guards like eddie bravo for example, i dont even think he teaches bjj in the gi. which is what bjj actually is. and yes i know he is a BB but does not currently train in the gi nor does he instruct or rank poeple in the gi. nothing against him just using as an example. if the question was "is JJ a black rashguard" or whatever you want to call it i would lean a little more towards yes. |
| 9/23/12 9:09 PM | |
|
Winston Wolf
Member Since: 1/1/01 Posts: 32705 |
Immaculata -Winston Wolf -uniquetechnique -Immaculata -Winston Wolf -Immaculata -Smith1234 -Immaculata - You need to be proficient with the Gi to be a true BB. I don't know the extent of his training using one. belt aint gunna do shit for u when ur going against an athlete with skill strength and conditioning .U could put a pink belt on Jones and hed still whoop ass |
| 9/23/12 9:11 PM | |
drance2624
7
Member Since: 2/28/07 Posts: 1693 |
he does have the most submission wins in UFC 205lb history...that might say something.... |
| 9/23/12 9:12 PM | |
|
Winston Wolf
Member Since: 1/1/01 Posts: 32706 |
uniquetechnique -Winston Wolf -Random Hero - MMA is not BJJ. he would not have a chance in a BJJ tournament against a BB. just because he beats a BB in MMA doesnt mean he beats a BB in jiu jitsu. thats like saying Randy is better at boxing than Toney because he beat him in MMA. they are two different sports. MMA grappling isnt even close to no gi grappling nvm actual brazilian jiu jitsu. its a whole different game when you add strikes. untill they start ranking MMA fighters with belt colours, he is not a black belt. in my opinion his striking is a bigger asset to his ground game than his grappling is. gimme a break I got my purple in GI.Yes I know the grips and coller chokes etc make it different But not that much that witha GI I can all of a sudden beat Jones.Im a purple belt and Jones would kick the ever living crap out of me with or without GI |
| 9/23/12 9:12 PM | |
Smith1234
12
Member Since: 1/2/06 Posts: 5089 |
disconnect - is this even a question? jones would get tapped easily by the WORST bb in his weight division at the bjj worlds. Do you have any perspective? Since when can all Black Belts do well or not get smoked at BJJ worlds? |
| 9/23/12 9:13 PM | |
drance2624
7
Member Since: 2/28/07 Posts: 1694 |
yellow wrkahlc -Smith1234 - ^^ huh? Please go rewatch the fight. I have no idea what you are saying. He was going back for leg, Shogun opened up and a bomb was landed. It is not up for debate, the punch was set up and the set up worked. he definitely set that punch up you're either blind or a self-righteous cunt if you think otherwise |
| 9/23/12 9:14 PM | |
disconnect
6
Member Since: 3/16/07 Posts: 274 |
Smith1234 - ^^ you seem smart. Stop being so dogmatic. Think beyond the gi. Looks beyond it to the core of what you HAVE seen without the gi. Base your answer on that. do you even realize what you're saying? you're asking this guy to rank jones by putting aside the very thing that separates actual bjj from submission wrestling or no gi grappling...the gi. jiu jitsu with gi & grappling without it are 2 different worlds. |
| 9/23/12 9:15 PM | |
|
Winston Wolf
Member Since: 1/1/01 Posts: 32707 |
disconnect - is this even a question? jones would get tapped easily by the WORST bb in his weight division at the bjj worlds. ya right |
| 9/23/12 9:16 PM | |
yellow wrkahlc
39
Member Since: 6/9/12 Posts: 2019 |
drance2624 -yellow wrkahlc -Smith1234 - ^^ huh? Please go rewatch the fight. I have no idea what you are saying. He was going back for leg, Shogun opened up and a bomb was landed. It is not up for debate, the punch was set up and the set up worked. HAHAHA! Then I guess I'm either blind or a "self-righteous cunt". I don't even think you know what self-righteous means... I'm not trashing Jon Jones, I'm just stating the obvious. Thanks for the VD, though. |
| 9/23/12 9:17 PM | |
|
Gomrad
Member Since: 7/21/09 Posts: 269 |
When it comes to MMA fighting BJJ is not the mystical force it once was... Man for man Wrestling produces better athletes / fighters then BJJ. This fact is hard for some pee to deal with... Ex: King Mo's Right Pimp Hand proved to be stronger then 10x World BJJ Champion chin.
|
| 9/23/12 9:18 PM | |
the ridler
78
Member Since: 6/22/04 Posts: 983 |
Winston Wolf -Kostakio - I wouldn't say he's a black belt but high purple or even a brown belt for sure. But of course, with his athleticism and confidence, he sure seems like it. Weidman was subbed by Vinny M in about 2 minutes in nogi. Weidman would win easily IMO if it was mma. Jones dominating in mma does not mean he would dominate in bjj, especially gi. Why do you think jones would out grapple couture? To me it's jones wrestling,reach,creativity and striking that make him what he is. |
| 9/23/12 9:20 PM | |
Smith1234
12
Member Since: 1/2/06 Posts: 5090 |
disconnect -Smith1234 - ^^ you seem smart. Stop being so dogmatic. Think beyond the gi. Looks beyond it to the core of what you HAVE seen without the gi. Base your answer on that. No, they are not two different worlds. They are two very similar worlds. Why do you think guys who trane the vast majority of the time in the gi also do well at ADCC? Please think about this and realize the incontrovertable truth of the matter. Let me explain what two different worlds are. BJJ is a different world from football, swimming and baseball. |
| 9/23/12 9:21 PM | |
Immaculata
46
Member Since: 12/14/03 Posts: 20798 |
Winston Wolf -Immaculata -Winston Wolf -uniquetechnique -Immaculata -Winston Wolf -Immaculata -Smith1234 -Immaculata - You need to be proficient with the Gi to be a true BB. I don't know the extent of his training using one. Again, you're missing the point. |
| 9/23/12 9:21 PM | |
|
MMAforMONEY
Member Since: 11/24/11 Posts: 27 MMAforMoney, President |
No, but he will be. He said last night at the press conference that BJJ is his weakness. And even though he likes to call himself a true "mixed" martial artist, that's the one art he struggles in. But he also said that he wants to focus on that next, and really spend a lot of time improving in it and getting comfortable with it. Give it time, he's pretty high-level now as it is, and when he focuses on it like he said, he's really going to be nasty!
|
| 9/23/12 9:23 PM | |
uniquetechnique
9
Member Since: 3/28/02 Posts: 4094 |
Winston Wolf -uniquetechnique -Winston Wolf -Immaculata -Winston Wolf -Immaculata -Smith1234 -Immaculata - You need to be proficient with the Gi to be a true BB. I don't know the extent of his training using one. Winston, I have trained BJJ since 1995. I held a purple for 6 years and a brown for 2. My black belt is still to many controversial...since it was my good friend that awarded it to me. I retired in 2008 because of 2 serious back tears and knee surgeries that never recovered right. I have seen many many highly skilled Division 1 wrestlers, Sambo guys, MMA guys who have never put a Gi on in their life. You have a BJJ guy pull you in guard or even butterfly guard with handles......it sucks for the other guy. You should know..you lived it as well. There are just so so many chokes with the Gi, so so many sweeps, so so many submissions. |
Reply Post
You must log in to post a reply. Click here to login.



