UnderGround Forums

UnderGround Forums >> So Who Is The Greatest HW Of All Time?

| Share | Email | Subscribe | Check IPs

2/5/13 2:06 PM
Ignore | Quote | Vote Down | Vote Up
35 The total sum of your votes up and votes down Send Private Message Add Comment To Profile

Member Since: 11/3/03
Posts: 2791
newbornbabynoob - As a Fedor fan this thread makes my heart smile. Remember when this forum was full of idiots shitting on Fedor and proclaiming Brock the #1 heavyweight? Because there was a LOT of them, like a significant portion of the forum.

It's nice to see some clear thinking in these parts again.

2/5/13 3:41 PM
Ignore | Quote | Vote Down | Vote Up
Send Private Message Add Comment To Profile

Member Since: 4/25/11
Posts: 277
ThinkMMA -
LAE - 
ThinkMMA -
LAE - Nogueria. He lost to Fedor twice I know but he was fighting all the contenders while Fedor was fighting Zulu and Mark Hunt. Phone Post
Nog fought Zulu. Your point? Phone Post
Fedor is recognised for his run in pride. For me Nog had the better run in Pride. He fought Ricco, barnett, sergei, finished herring and finished crocop. Fedors only two siginificant wins were Nog and Cro cop but that doesnt make him greater overall. For me it will be Nogueria, he went to the UFC and has better and more relevant wins than Fedor since 2006. Fedor (through no fault of his own i admit) didnt fight those top guys because Nogueria fought them for him.

Its the same situation between Wanderlei and Shogun in PRIDE. Wanderlei got all the plaudits and everyone talks of hos amazing title run. All wand did was beat up cans and undersized Japanese guys. He beat Page twice and went 1-1 with Arona. Shogun beat page, nog, overeem and arona in the GP, Wands biggest win was nakamura ffs.

Pride liked to protect its stars. As doon as Shogun won the GP and became a star who did they give him? The Snake ffs.

Dont get me wrong, i am fan of all the fighters ive mentioned but just look at who they had to fight.

Fedor faded into obscurity because of M1, Nog is still relevant. Phone Post

Cool set of paragraphs. 


They both had great runs, but, what happens when they fight????  Okay then.

Posting from my phone, apologies for layout. However, you didnt really answer my point. By your system of If X bests Y he's immediately greater than him. Therefore is Rampage greater than Chuck in the LHW GOAT standing? Is Bang better than Pulver? Is Aurelio better than Gomi?

We're talking about legacy. For me, Nog fought the tougher guys while Fedor didnt. I admit, he beat Nog and CroCop but didnt test himself against Sergei, Barnett, Ricco etc. Its matchmakings fault, not Fedors. Phone Post

| Share | Email | Subscribe | Check IPs

Reply Post

You must log in to post a reply. Click here to login.