UnderGround Forums Matt Brown thinks he got screwed by the judges

1/16/21 11:13 PM
6/9/16
Posts: 10193

1/16/21 11:17 PM
3/29/13
Posts: 163

Well he has a point in that he did win the 1st round. It wasnt a blowout but  but the right guy won. 

1/17/21 12:06 AM
3/5/15
Posts: 2060

I scored the first for Condit. 

 

He was much busier while Matt mostly looked lost.

1/17/21 10:52 AM
1/1/01
Posts: 60893
Sorry Matt, 3rd round was not close but the 1st round was.
1/17/21 11:03 AM
1/1/01
Posts: 52722

I could tell immediately when Buffer said “All three judges scored if 30-27.....” that Matt thought he had absolutely won round 1. 

1/17/21 11:09 AM
2/17/03
Posts: 17534
Wasa-B - Sorry Matt, 3rd round was not close but the 1st round was.

Agreed.

Easy fight to score for Condit. I had it 29-28, but I understand and maybe even prefer judging that has it at 30-27.

1/17/21 1:06 PM
1/1/01
Posts: 60901
http://mmadecisions.com/decision/11639/Carlos-Condit-vs-Matt-Brown

Most had it 29-28 but a few had 30-27. Either way, he lost R2, 3 clearly. I dont think R3 was close.
1/17/21 1:08 PM
1/1/01
Posts: 60902
At the least the judges were not automatically giving fighters rounds for being on top. I think i had the round for Brown but it was close enough.
1/17/21 1:18 PM
6/26/03
Posts: 3858

yea i gave matt the first.. the third was close if you count damage not just strikes.

1/17/21 1:49 PM
1/1/01
Posts: 49566

first was close 2nd and 3rd Condit won imo

1/17/21 1:55 PM
10/3/11
Posts: 1156
Samoa -

I could tell immediately when Buffer said “All three judges scored if 30-27.....” that Matt thought he had absolutely won round 1. 

WOW! Could you tell by the immediate reaction on his face that was visible to anyone with working eyes?

You must be some sort of superhuman. Maybe you should fight Condit next!

1/17/21 2:37 PM
11/28/03
Posts: 112552

look at the media scores

 

http://mmadecisions.com/decision/11639/Carlos-Condit-vs-Matt-Brown

1/17/21 4:18 PM
12/9/12
Posts: 443

Being on top doing close to nothing shouldn't win you a round, and in this case didn't. Condit split Matt's forehead when he got taken down, and did much more off his back than Matt did from top position. R2 and R3 no discussion, so either 30-27 or 29-28, clear win for CC. 

1/17/21 4:55 PM
5/15/09
Posts: 6211

Show me where in the scoring criteria it says ending a round on top means you win it please.

1/17/21 5:01 PM
7/29/13
Posts: 7210

I only gave him the first 

1/17/21 5:24 PM
10/14/10
Posts: 15705

First, yes. Condit won. WAR NBK!

1/17/21 6:05 PM
1/1/01
Posts: 52724
lamedroid - 
Samoa -

I could tell immediately when Buffer said “All three judges scored if 30-27.....” that Matt thought he had absolutely won round 1. 

WOW! Could you tell by the immediate reaction on his face that was visible to anyone with working eyes?

You must be some sort of superhuman. Maybe you should fight Condit next!


I'll see if they will let me!  SUPERhuman!  I will definitely act on that.

1/17/21 6:05 PM
2/17/03
Posts: 17547
lamedroid - 
Samoa -

I could tell immediately when Buffer said “All three judges scored if 30-27.....” that Matt thought he had absolutely won round 1. 

WOW! Could you tell by the immediate reaction on his face that was visible to anyone with working eyes?

You must be some sort of superhuman. Maybe you should fight Condit next!


Relax.

1/18/21 9:21 AM
8/6/06
Posts: 52715


1/18/21 10:04 AM
1/1/01
Posts: 627

Matt's being a baby. He just took him down and laid on him for 5 mins. Condit scored from the bottom.

1/18/21 10:10 AM
7/29/13
Posts: 7237

Condit definitely won. He did more from all positions. He was even more active while on the bottom. 

1/18/21 10:31 AM
11/10/05
Posts: 7682
not calling that fight and/or having Matt win on the scorecards would've been a disgrace to mma judging.
1/18/21 12:58 PM
11/3/06
Posts: 5538
lamedroid -
Samoa -

I could tell immediately when Buffer said “All three judges scored if 30-27.....” that Matt thought he had absolutely won round 1. 

WOW! Could you tell by the immediate reaction on his face that was visible to anyone with working eyes?

You must be some sort of superhuman. Maybe you should fight Condit next!

I can appreciate the sarcasm and this had potential. Unfortunately you went too far and ended up sounding like a douchebag. Keep working at it, you'll learn the subtle nuances required to not cross that line.

1/18/21 12:59 PM
5/13/05
Posts: 8619

Condit did all the work from the bottom while Brown tried to ride out the top position. He lost all 3 rounds imo.

1/19/21 12:41 PM
7/24/12
Posts: 10087

Matt Brown pretty much said that he knew he lost but thought it was bullshit that they gave condit all 3 rounds. 

 

You clearly lost either way, who cares?