Skip to main content

Gun expert vs. knife expert (unedited)

Elite knife fighter vs. elite gunfighter - unedited!
  • Author:
  • Publish date:
Knife Expert vs. Gun Expert (unedited) - Who has the faster weapon?

Knife Expert vs. Gun Expert (unedited) - Who has the faster weapon?

This article from MixedMartialArts.com is part of a long effort to learn what works, by observing what happens outside the arena. Check out more Top Ranked stories on:
Weapons
Martial Arts on The Street
Mutual Combat


Self-defense against a weapon is one of the most popular topics in martial arts, and it's potentially fatal. So what happens when you take two of the most popular weapons of choice - the gun and the knife - and pit them against each other?

On the surface, it may seem like a no-brainer that a person with a firearm will win this scenario. However, two self-defense instructors decided to really put this to the test. 

In the below videos, self-defense expert Doug Marcaida from Funker Tactical brings in firearms expert Instructor Zero to conduct live drills involving a knife versus a firearm.

Before they start, Instructor Zero makes a crucial point - that his reactions will differ due to the fact that he already knows that Doug is threatening with a knife. He acknowledges that if it were in real life, the element of surprise would be much greater, and thus awareness of surroundings is a key to success.

They first start off the drill with Instructor Zero having his back turned, while Doug is roughly 10 feet away. At random points, Doug runs toward Zero with his knife, while Zero has to quickly draw his pistol and shoot Doug before any harm comes to himself.

Initially, Doug has no problems closing the distance and reaching Zero with his knife, due to the fact Zero has to first lift up his shirt where his weapon is concealed, draw it, aim it, and then fire.

With this in mind, Zero tries an alternative tactic to make up for the time to draw his weapon.

Find out how he resolves this problem below.

LINK

Elite Gun Fighter vs Elite Knife Fighter Episode 1

LINK

Elite Gun Fighter vs Elite Knife Fighter Episode 2

LINK

Share your thoughts on a gun vs. a knife, on The StreetGround Forum at MixedMartialArts.com.